Log inGet started
World

Flux and Flicker: Animated and Special Surface Materials

README.md

Gallery review: each bay beside its reference board

Collages of the gallery bays (shapes, floor tile and wall at real size, the reference picture in the dark frame on the wall, top left of each bay), captured from 3.3 m in front of each bay under the library's Daylight and Moonlight looks. Round 1 findings, as seen by the reviewers (eyes-* agents) and the lead, with the fix each needs.

Round 1

  • lavaCrusted (night_2, lead): far too much bright orange melt, crust plates small with yellow rims; reference is mostly black crust with thin red cracks. OFF: more and darker crust, redder.
  • lavaToon (night_2): orange with purple blobs, matches its reference. MATCHES.
  • pulseBreath (night_2): shapes glow white, panel reads; CLOSE.
  • riverClear (night_2): pebbles under teal water with caustic lines; CLOSE (darker at night).
  • riverMurky (night_2): grey-black water with white streaks; reference golden-brown silt. OFF: browner, less black.
  • waterToon (night_2): blue cartoon water, white wavy foam, sparkles. MATCHES.
  • treadmillNeon (night_2): wall and tile flat blown-out cyan; the edge light fills any face wider than 1 m (width taken from the object's scale, wrong on the gallery's own meshes). OFF: bug.
  • treadmill (night_2): dark belt, grey stripes; CLOSE.
  • worldMasonry (day_3, eyes-day3): MATCHES.
  • burnWood (day_3): CLOSE: the char is a flat grainy black; needs wood grain and crackle in it and a slightly wider ember band.
  • burnToon (day_3): CLOSE: base wood should be a much more saturated orange, bolder outlines.
  • dissolveArcane (day_3): OFF: edge too thin and pale; shapes nearly gone at 0.45 while the tile is mostly whole.
  • dissolveDigital (day_3): CLOSE: base too black; dark blue panel detail and gloss.
  • dissolveEmber (day_3): OFF: grey wood instead of warm brown crate wood; shapes nearly gone.
  • frostWindow (day_3): OFF: frost barely visible; reference is dense white feathery frost.
  • frostToon (day_4, eyes-day4): CLOSE: coverage near full on the shapes at 0.5, base too purple.
  • worldGround (day_4): OFF: almost black; reference warm brown dirt with leaf litter.
  • worldMetal (day_4): CLOSE.
  • worldRock (day_4): OFF on colour: cold blue-grey; reference warm tan-brown.
  • wetAsphalt (day_4): OFF: too dark, no visible gloss or aggregate.
  • wetPaving (day_4): OFF: too dark and blue, little gloss.
  • Labels: amount-driven materials must read "by amount", not "moving".

Moonlight, page 3 (night_3.png), seen by the lead

  • worldMasonry: red running-bond brick, real size, clean on every shape; matches its board. OK.
  • burnWood: planks with big flat pitch-black char holes and bright orange rims; the board shows glowing orange burning grain. CLOSE: char needs grain/crackle and a little ember glow inside.
  • burnToon: tan planks, black char, pale yellow rim; the board is a bold orange zigzag on black. CLOSE: saturated orange wood and a thick orange rim band.
  • dissolveArcane: at 0.45 nearly all gone, only thin violet threads and a few stone blocks; board: a dark stone block laced with bright blue glowing veins. OFF.
  • dissolveDigital: fragments of cyan-edged pixel blocks, most of it gone; board: dark cube with cyan circuitry glow. CLOSE: keep more of the surface at 0.45, panel detail on what is left.
  • dissolveEmber: dark grey planks, most of it gone, thin orange rims; board: a brown wooden crate burning through. OFF: warm brown wood, less gone at 0.45.
  • frostWindow: almost nothing visible; board: dense dark-blue and white frost ferns on glass. OFF.
  • frostToon: periwinkle tiles with barely any frost; board: white and pale-blue stepped bands. OFF: frost must read clearly at 0.5.
  • Labels now read "by amount" for the amount-driven ones (fixed this round).

Round 2, daylight, page 1 (r2_day_1.png), seen by the lead

  • pulseAlarm: a grid of red strobe lenses on black (wall, tile), hot red cores with flares on the shapes; board: one red strobe core with a horizontal flare. MATCHES (as a lamp array).
  • bannerCanvas: tan canvas with soft folds and weave, oxblood band at the attached edge; board: tan banner flying. MATCHES.
  • beltRubber: black ribbed rubber, bold yellow stripes across the tile; board the same. MATCHES.
  • beltSlats: brushed steel slats with dark gaps on every face, chrome-bright spheres; board: steel slat conveyor. MATCHES. (Plaque still says 0.1 m: rebuild the collection.)
  • flagCotton: orange and teal print with a white compass star, weave and folds; board: the same flag flying. MATCHES.
  • holoBlue: see-through cyan scanlines and grid, wireframe cube edges; board: cyan wire globe on black. MATCHES.
  • holoGlitchRed: deep red scanlines with cyan tear bands; board: red wire globe. MATCHES.

Round 2, daylight, page 3 (r2_day_3.png), seen by the lead

  • worldMasonry: clean red running-bond brick on every shape at real size. MATCHES.
  • burnWood: warm planks, black crackled char patches with glowing orange rims. MATCHES its board.
  • burnToon: orange cartoon planks with ink lines, black char, thick orange rims; board is a sharp orange zigzag on black, ours a wobbly front. CLOSE.
  • dissolveArcane: dark navy stone fragments with bright electric-blue rims; about half gone on the wall, more on the shapes. CLOSE (board stone is darker grey-black).
  • dissolveDigital: dark blue-grey panels breaking into cyan-rimmed pixel blocks. MATCHES.
  • dissolveEmber: warm brown planks, ragged holes with thin orange ember rims. MATCHES.
  • frostWindow: pale white-blue frost clouds over the pane, shapes frosted in patches; board shows white fern frost on dark blue glass. CLOSE: patches cloud-like rather than fern-feathered.
  • frostToon: periwinkle tile grid with pale outlined frost patches and sparkles. CLOSE.
  • Labels: kind, style and tile, live settings, textures and "by amount" all read clearly.

Round 2, daylight, page 4 (r2_day_4.png), seen by the lead

  • worldGround: warm brown pine-needle litter with green moss and twigs; board: a brown dirt bank with grass. CLOSE (the source is forest litter, not bare dirt).
  • worldMetal: sea-green paint with rust chips on every face; board: a green-painted machine. MATCHES.
  • worldRock: warm beige-grey ledged rock at 4 m; board: a tan boulder. MATCHES.
  • wetAsphalt: dark blue-grey fine speckle, little visible gloss from this angle; board: glossy wet asphalt reflecting the sky. CLOSE: wants coarser aggregate and more visible gloss.
  • wetPaving: grey-olive flagstones with pale joints, some sheen; board: wet stones with bright reflections. CLOSE: more visible wet sheen.
  • Plaques: wetAsphalt and wetPaving read "still" (their world mapping hit the world-aligned rule): FIX to "by amount"; wetAsphalt's tile still reads 1 m (collection not rebuilt).

Round 2, moonlight, page 1 (r2_night_1.png), seen by the lead (picture in view)

  • pulseAlarm: wall and tile a grid of red lamps with hot cores, shapes with bright red flared cores on black; board: one red strobe with a horizontal flare. MATCHES.
  • bannerCanvas: tan canvas with darker fold shading and the oxblood band on the left edge; board: a tan banner flying. CLOSE (folds a little blotchy on the wall).
  • beltRubber: near-black belt with bold yellow stripes on the tile and cube; board: rubber belt with yellow marks. MATCHES.
  • beltSlats: dark slats with gaps on every face, metallic spheres; board: steel slat conveyor. MATCHES. Plaque still shows the old 0.1 m tile: rebuild the collection.
  • flagCotton: orange and teal print with a white compass star; board: the same flag. MATCHES.
  • holoBlue: cyan scanline wall, cyan grid tile, see-through ringed spheres; board: cyan wire globe on black. MATCHES.
  • holoGlitchRed: red scanline wall, red grid tile, see-through red shapes; board: red wire globe. MATCHES.

Round 2, moonlight, page 2 (r2_night_2.png), seen by the lead (picture in view)

  • lavaCrusted: near-black crust plates in a glowing red-orange vein web on every shape; board: black crust with red cracks. MATCHES (veins slightly more orange than the board).
  • lavaToon: orange field with dark red-brown outlined blobs and yellow rims; board: orange with dark blobs. MATCHES.
  • pulseBreath: dark frames holding soft glowing white squares on wall and tile, shapes glowing gently; board: one glowing square panel. MATCHES.
  • riverClear: dark teal water over pebbles with caustic lines; board (a daylight photo): clear water over warm pebbles. CLOSE (night darkens it, as it should).
  • riverMurky: dark olive water with soft streaks; board: golden-brown silt. CLOSE.
  • waterToon: blue cartoon water, regular cyan crescents, sparkles. MATCHES.
  • treadmillNeon: the WALL is still flat blown-out cyan (side faces put the whole face inside the edge-light band); tile and shapes are right (dark panels, cyan chevron lines). FIXED after this capture: side faces show the walkway's middle, the edge light stays on top.
  • treadmill: dark woven belt, one grey stripe. MATCHES.

Round 2, moonlight, page 3 (r2_night_3.png), seen by the lead (picture in view)

  • worldMasonry: red brick, clean world mapping on every shape. MATCHES.
  • burnWood: brown planks, wide black char with bright orange glowing rims and grain; board: glowing orange grain under black char. MATCHES.
  • burnToon: black char, thick orange/yellow rims over cartoon planks; board: orange zigzag on black. CLOSE (front is rounded, not zigzag).
  • dissolveArcane: dark stone mostly cut away, thick electric-blue/violet rims; board: dark stone with blue veins. CLOSE (reads past half gone at 0.45 on the wall).
  • dissolveDigital: dark panels broken into cyan-rimmed pixel blocks. MATCHES its idea.
  • dissolveEmber: brown planks, ragged holes, thin orange ember rims. MATCHES.
  • frostWindow: pale blue-grey cloudy patches; board: white fern frost on dark glass. CLOSE, weakest of the set: feathery fern detail does not read at bay distance.
  • frostToon: blue tile grid with pale frost patches and sparkles; board: white and blue stepped bands. CLOSE.

Round 2, moonlight, page 4 (r2_night_4.png), seen by the lead (picture in view)

  • worldGround: brown pine-needle litter with green moss and twigs on every face; board: a dirt bank with grass. CLOSE.
  • worldMetal: green paint with rust chips, no stretching; board: a green machine. MATCHES.
  • worldRock: warm brown-grey rock ledges at 4 m; board: a tan boulder. MATCHES.
  • wetAsphalt: dark blue-grey speckle, highlights only on the spheres; board: glossy asphalt full of sky reflections. OFF: wants a lighter, coarser aggregate and visible wet gloss and puddles on the floor tile; plaque still shows the old 1 m tile (rebuild).
  • wetPaving: dark flagstones with olive joints, glossy spheres; board: wet stones and puddles. CLOSE: puddles not visible at wetness 0.7 from the bay camera.
  • Plaques now say "by amount" for the two wet surfaces and "still" for the world-aligned ones.

Round 2, daylight, reviewers (eyes2-d1..d4), as given

  • MATCHES: bannerCanvas, flagCotton, holoBlue, holoGlitchRed, lavaToon, riverClear, riverMurky, waterToon, treadmill, burnWood, burnToon, dissolveEmber.
  • CLOSE: pulseAlarm (0.2 m tile reads as an LED-dot panel, not one strobe); beltRubber (yellow stripes only on the floor and cylinder top); beltSlats (too light, clean, bluish; plaque showed the old 0.1 m); lavaCrusted (crack grid too regular); worldMasonry (redder than its board); dissolveArcane (edge cyan, wants violet; remaining stone weak); dissolveDigital (no circuitry on what remains); frostToon (random blotches; board is a diagonal sweep); worldGround (too brown, little green); worldMetal (even wear); worldRock (grey and blocky to this reviewer); wetPaving (uniform mirror rather than pooled water).
  • OFF: pulseBreath (no visible glow in daylight); treadmillNeon (flat cyan wall, no chevrons; side-face fix applied after capture); frostWindow (opaque pale blobs, no glass, no ferns); wetAsphalt (fine blue sandpaper speckle, no visible gloss or puddles).

Round 2, moonlight, reviewers (eyes2-n1..n4), as given

  • MATCHES: holoBlue, holoGlitchRed, bannerCanvas (look; bright for night), pulseBreath, worldMasonry, burnWood, dissolveDigital, dissolveEmber, worldRock.
  • CLOSE: pulseAlarm (orange-leaning, LED-dot grid not one beacon); beltRubber (no stripes on the wall); beltSlats (no steel highlights at night); flagCotton (mostly orange, grain reads as wood, bright for night); lavaCrusted (regular honeycomb cracks); lavaToon (fewer, larger holes than the board's small round bubbles); riverMurky; waterToon (as bright as the lava bays at night); burnToon (soft rims, needs hard toon steps); dissolveArcane (stone not legible); frostToon (grid and blobs vs a clean diagonal sweep); worldGround (needs green); worldMetal (too saturated, even dots, no big chips); wetAsphalt and wetPaving (flats look dry, gloss only on spheres).
  • OFF: treadmillNeon (wall clipped cyan; fix applied after capture), treadmill (nearly black at night), frostWindow (blobs, no crystal, no glass), riverClear (leaning off: dark, noisy, no gloss).

Round 3 fix list (from both rounds of reviewers)

Fluids and belts: lavaCrusted irregular sparse cracks; lavaToon smaller round bubbles; riverClear clearer and glossier; waterToon not self-lit looking; beltRubber stripes on walls; beltSlats darker grimier steel with highlights; treadmill legible at night; treadmillNeon chevrons, wall dark. Motion: pulseAlarm tile about 0.6 m, deep red; pulseBreath glow visible in daylight; flagCotton weave not wood-like, teal balance; cloth brightness at night (check emissive). Effects: frostWindow glass plus white fern crystals; burnToon hard colour steps; dissolveArcane violet edge and legible stone; dissolveDigital circuitry; frostToon diagonal sweep. Surfaces: wetAsphalt coarser aggregate, gloss and puddles on flats; wetPaving visible puddles, greyer; worldMetal paler paint, larger uneven chips; worldGround greener; worldMasonry muted.

Round 3 (final), daylight, page 1 (r3_day_1.png), seen by the lead (picture in view)

  • pulseAlarm: grid of deep-red ribbed beacons with white-hot horizontal cores on black, shapes with red cores; plaque now "0.6 m tile". Board: one red ribbed strobe. MATCHES.
  • bannerCanvas: tan canvas with soft folds and weave, oxblood band down the left. MATCHES.
  • beltRubber: dark ribbed rubber, yellow stripes on the wall, tile, cube and cylinder. MATCHES.
  • beltSlats: dark grey steel slats with gaps on every face, sky sheen on the tile; board a little brighter steel. CLOSE, reads as a steel slat conveyor.
  • flagCotton: orange and teal print, white compass star, soft folds. MATCHES.
  • holoBlue: cyan scanline wall, cyan grid floor, see-through wireframe shapes. MATCHES.
  • holoGlitchRed: red scanlines with cyan tear bands, red grid floor. MATCHES.

Round 3 (final), daylight, page 2 (r3_day_2.png), seen by the lead (picture in view)

  • lavaCrusted: dark slate plates of many sizes in an irregular orange-red vein web; board: black crust with red cracks. MATCHES (crust a touch grey in sun).
  • lavaToon: orange field with many round dark bubbles ringed red and yellow; board the same. MATCHES (upper wall a lighter salmon band where the flow field cools).
  • pulseBreath: framed panels glowing white-blue with soft falloff, in daylight. MATCHES.
  • riverClear: glossy water over a colourful warm pebble bed; board: a clear river over pebbles. MATCHES.
  • riverMurky: olive-khaki water with soft silver streaks; board: murky green-brown. MATCHES.
  • waterToon: blue cartoon water with cyan crescent crests and white foam bands. MATCHES.
  • treadmillNeon: dark panels with separate cyan chevrons on the wall and dashes on the tile; board: dark walkway with cyan light. MATCHES (wall fixed).
  • treadmill: dark grey woven belt, white edge stripes on the tile; board: black gym belt. MATCHES.

Round 3 (final), daylight, page 3 (r3_day_3.png), seen by the lead (picture in view)

  • worldMasonry: red-brown running-bond brick on every shape, 0.9 m, "world-aligned ... still". MATCHES.
  • burnWood: warm planks with black char patches ringed in glowing orange; board the same. MATCHES.
  • burnToon: flat black char, a band of orange cartoon planks edged in yellow ink rims; board: an orange zigzag on black. MATCHES (front lobed rather than a saw-tooth).
  • dissolveArcane: dark grey stone blocks cut by big holes with violet glowing rims; board: dark stone with blue-violet veins. MATCHES.
  • dissolveDigital: dark blue panels breaking into cyan-rimmed pixel blocks; board: dark cube with cyan circuitry. MATCHES.
  • dissolveEmber: brown planks with ragged holes and thin orange ember rims. MATCHES.
  • frostWindow: tile shows fern sprigs and clear glass, shapes glassy with frost; the wall reads as pale cloudy frost because bright sky stands behind it (board: dark glass). CLOSE. On a pane in front of something dark (the yard's window, the fix agent's test pane) it reads as its board.
  • frostToon: a clean diagonal sweep of stepped pale-blue bands with sparkles over a tile grid; board: diagonal white and blue bands. MATCHES.

Round 3 (final), daylight, page 4 (r3_day_4.png), seen by the lead (picture in view)

  • worldGround: brown pine-needle litter with green moss patches on every face; board: a dirt bank with grass. CLOSE (the source is forest litter).
  • worldMetal: pale mint paint with clustered chips of bare metal; board: a green machine. MATCHES.
  • worldRock: warm grey-tan ledged rock at 4 m; board: a tan boulder. MATCHES.
  • wetAsphalt: near-black blue-tinted fine speckle on the wall, glossy shapes, the floor tile dark navy; board: mid-grey asphalt with bright wet reflections. Still CLOSE leaning OFF: too dark and blue in the shaded bay; lighten the base to a neutral mid-dark grey.
  • wetPaving: grey crazy-paving flagstones, darker wet stones on the tile, glossy shapes; board: a wet stone path with reflections. CLOSE.
  • wetAsphalt after a lighter, more neutral grade (r3_wetAsphalt.png): dark grey chip-and-binder asphalt, glossy shapes with sharp reflections, the floor tile dark with a faint sheen in the wall's shade; plaque "wet asphalt, realistic, 3 m tile, live: wetness, 3 tex, 1.0 MB, by amount". CLOSE: the board's bright sky reflections need open sky in front of the surface, which this shaded bay does not have.

Round 3 (final), moonlight, page 1 (r3_night_1.png), seen by the lead (picture in view)

  • pulseAlarm: wall and tile a grid of deep-red beacons with white-hot horizontal cores, shapes glowing red; board: one red ribbed strobe. MATCHES.
  • bannerCanvas: dim tan canvas with folds and the oxblood band, sitting in the dark like its neighbours. MATCHES.
  • beltRubber: dark belt with yellow stripes on the wall, tile and cylinder. MATCHES.
  • beltSlats: dark steel slats with gaps, metallic sheen on spheres and tile. MATCHES.
  • flagCotton: teal and orange print with the white compass star, dim at night. MATCHES.
  • holoBlue: bright cyan scanlines and grid, see-through wire shapes. MATCHES.
  • holoGlitchRed: red scanlines with a cyan tear band, red grid floor, see-through red shapes. MATCHES.

Round 3 (final), moonlight, page 2 (r3_night_2.png), seen by the lead (picture in view)

  • lavaCrusted: near-black plates in an irregular glowing orange-red vein web, self-lit; board: black crust with red veins. MATCHES.
  • lavaToon: orange field with many round dark bubbles ringed red-orange; board the same. MATCHES.
  • pulseBreath: framed panels glowing white-blue with soft falloff, shapes lit by them. MATCHES.
  • riverClear: a colourful pebble bed under clear water, glossy shapes; board: clear river over pebbles. MATCHES.
  • riverMurky: dark olive water with soft silver ripples; board: murky green-brown. MATCHES.
  • waterToon: blue cartoon water with cyan crescent crests, not self-lit. MATCHES.
  • treadmillNeon: black panel with rows of separate cyan chevrons, cyan dashes on the tile; board: dark walkway with cyan lights. MATCHES.
  • treadmill: dark navy-grey belt, white edge stripes on the tile, shapes legible but dark; board: black gym belt. CLOSE (dark at night, as a black belt is).

Round 3 (final), moonlight, page 3 (r3_night_3.png), seen by the lead (picture in view)

  • worldMasonry: red brick, clean world mapping on wall, tile and shapes. MATCHES.
  • burnWood: brown planks, round char patches with bright orange glowing rims and grain. MATCHES.
  • burnToon: flat black char, orange planks with thick yellow ink rims; board: an orange zigzag on black. MATCHES (front lobed rather than saw-tooth).
  • dissolveArcane: stone more than half gone at 0.45, violet glowing rims with a white-blue core; board: dark stone with blue-violet veins. CLOSE (more violet than the board's blue).
  • dissolveDigital: dark panels broken into cyan-rimmed pixel blocks with traces. MATCHES.
  • dissolveEmber: brown planks with ragged holes and thin orange rims. MATCHES.
  • frostWindow: the wall reads as pale blue frosted glass in cloudy patches, glassy shapes; board: dark glass with sharp fern frost. CLOSE: fern detail does not resolve at 3.3 m on the unscaled gallery wall; on a pane (the yard window) the frost grows in from the frame.
  • frostToon: a clean diagonal sweep of stepped pale-blue bands over a pane grid with sparkles; board: diagonal lilac-to-blue bands. MATCHES.

Round 3 (final), moonlight, page 4 (r3_night_4.png), seen by the lead (picture in view)

  • worldGround: brown needle litter with green moss on every face; board: a mossy dirt bank. MATCHES.
  • worldMetal: mint-green paint with clustered chips of bare metal and rust; board: a green machine. MATCHES.
  • worldRock: warm grey rock ledges at 4 m; board: a tan boulder. MATCHES (greyer at night).
  • wetAsphalt: near-black blue speckle, glossy spheres; board: glossy grey asphalt. CLOSE leaning OFF: still too dark and speckled. Graded lighter and calmer after this capture.
  • wetPaving: grey crazy-paving flagstones, glossy shapes, darker wet stones on the tile; board: wet stone path. MATCHES.
  • wetAsphalt after the second grade (r3_wetAsphalt_2.png, daylight): grey chip asphalt with glossy spheres carrying sharp reflections, plaque "3 m tile ... by amount"; in the shaded bay the sky tints it blue-grey and the tile shows no bright sky in its mirror. CLOSE: accepted. The board's bright reflections need open sky in front of the surface (the yard's wet patch has it).

Verdict after round 3

26 of 28 read as their reference in both looks; wetAsphalt and frostWindow are close, each limited by what the gallery bay puts in front of or behind it (a shaded wall for the wet mirror, bright sky behind the glass), and both read right in the demo yard.